First Amendment Challenge Prompts Maine AG to Postpone Enforcement of New Child Privacy Protection Law

On September 9, 2009, the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine dismissed a lawsuit challenging the validity of the Act to Prevent Predatory Marketing Practices Against Minors (the “Act”), which is set to take effect on September 12, 2009.  The Act prohibits businesses from knowingly collecting or receiving a minor’s health-related information or personal information for marketing purposes without first obtaining verifiable parental consent.  Businesses are also prohibited from using any health-related information or personal information regarding a minor for the purpose of marketing a product or service to the minor.  In dismissing the claim, the Court acknowledged that the Plaintiffs had successfully established the likelihood of success on the merits that the Act is overbroad and violates the First Amendment.  Although the Plaintiffs met this burden, the Court recognized that the Attorney General has agreed not to enforce the Act, and the Maine Legislature is committed to reconsidering its scope in January 2010.  Accordingly, the Court, with the agreement of the parties, closed the lawsuit in a stipulated order of dismissal.

Click here for details regarding the scope and requirements of the Act.

Maine Enacts Comprehensive New Law Restricting Marketing to Minors

On September 12, 2009, Maine’s Act to Prevent Predatory Marketing Practices Against Minors (the “Act”) will take effect.  The Act prohibits businesses from knowingly collecting or receiving a minor’s health-related information or personal information for marketing purposes without first obtaining verifiable parental consent.  Businesses are also prohibited from using any health-related information or personal information regarding a minor for the purpose of marketing a product or service to the minor.  Pursuant to the Act, the use of information in such a manner is a predatory marketing practice, which may be sanctioned as an unfair trade practice.  The law also allows individuals subject to unlawful data collection or predatory marketing practices to bring a private right of action against violators.

For businesses, the implications of Maine's new data collection and marketing restrictions are far-reaching.  The scope of the law covers both online and off-line marketing activities, and the broad definition of personal information includes a minor’s name in combination with any information concerning the minor.  In light of the Act’s restrictive requirements and considerable scope, businesses would be well-advised to evaluate their current marketing practices and age verification mechanisms.  The text of the law is available here.

Maine Requires Breach Notice within Seven Days of Go-Ahead from Law Enforcement

On May 19, Maine Governor John Baldacci signed legislation limiting the time that breach notification may be delayed following a determination by law enforcement that providing notice will not compromise a criminal investigation. The provision, which will take effect 90 days after the close of the Legislature's 2009 session (scheduled to occur on June 17), will limit the permissible delay to seven business days.

Pursuant to Maine's current breach notification law, entities that become aware of a breach "shall conduct in good faith a reasonable and prompt investigation to determine the likelihood that personal information has been or will be misused." If the entity concludes, following its investigation, that notification to affected individuals is required, notice may be delayed if a law enforcement agency determines that notice would "compromise a criminal investigation." Once the law enforcement agency concludes that notification will not compromise its criminal investigation, the entity will have no more than seven business days to provide notice of the breach to affected individuals.

Text of the legislation, L.D. 970, is available here.